A dispute between owners over obligations under section 58 of the Land Law is within the jurisdiction of the Condominium Superintendent (section 72(a)). An agreement to refer such a dispute to arbitration remains valid (section 72(d)).
House committee debt: who pays, how much, and how to collect?
Every apartment owner in a condominium must share in the costs needed for the proper upkeep and management of the common property. This is provided by section 58(a) of the Land Law, 5729-1969. When an owner does not pay, the building's representative committee may sue before the Condominium Superintendent, and the Superintendent's decision is enforced like a judgment.
The share is set by the ratio between the floor area of the apartment and the floor area of all the apartments in the building, unless the bylaws set a different share.
What do house committee fees pay for?
For the proper upkeep and management of the common property, and for services required by law or customary by practice.
The Law defines "proper upkeep" as keeping the common property in the condition it was in when construction was completed, including improvements made afterwards with the owners' consent. So cleaning, stairwell electricity, lift maintenance and repairs to the common property are costs everyone shares. A new improvement that was not agreed is a different question.
How much does each apartment pay?
The default under section 58(a) is by the floor area of the apartment relative to the floor area of all the apartments in the building. Agreed bylaws may set a different share. So before arguing over the amount, it is worth checking whether the building has registered bylaws and what they say. See the article condominium bylaws. On the question of roof apartments see roof apartments and house committee fees.
The costs themselves are set by the general meeting of the owners. In a building governed by the standard bylaws, the meeting convenes once a year, among other things to set the costs and approve the accounts (section 5 of the standard bylaws in the Schedule to the Land Law).
Who must pay: the owner or the tenant?
The duty in section 58 is on the apartment owner. A tenant may undertake in the lease to pay the house committee fees, but that is an agreement between the tenant and the landlord. Towards the building's committee, the owner is the one liable.
How is house committee debt collected?
- A written demand to the owner, with details of the debt and the period.
- A decision of the committee to file a claim. The committee is the agent of all the owners and may be a party to legal proceedings on their behalf (section 69 of the Law).
- A claim before the Condominium Superintendent. A dispute over obligations under section 58 is within the Superintendent's jurisdiction (section 72(a)), and the building's committee may bring it for decision (section 73).
- Enforcement. For enforcement and execution purposes, the Superintendent's decision has the status of a Magistrates' Court judgment (section 76).
The Superintendent's decision may be appealed to the District Court within 45 days of service (section 77 of the Law and regulation 83 of the Land Regulations (Management and Registration)). On the proceedings themselves see the Land Registration Superintendent.
And if the building is not registered as a condominium?
Even in a building not registered in the condominium register, the provisions on sharing costs and on the Superintendent's jurisdiction apply, under section 77B of the Law, and the building is run under the standard bylaws (section 77C).
What should the committee do in advance?
- Record every decision of the general meeting in the minute book. Under section 71(a), a recorded decision also binds anyone who becomes an owner later.
- Keep orderly accounts and present them to the owners.
- Send written payment demands, and not wait for the debt to build up for years.
Case law and sources
- The Land Law, 5729-1969: sections 58, 69, 71, 72, 73, 76, 77, 77B, 77C, and the standard bylaws in the Schedule (section 5).
- The Land Regulations (Management and Registration), 5772-2011: regulation 83.
About the author
Amos Ilan, Advocate, is a lawyer (Bar No. 35320) and a notary (licence 214444). The office is at 17 Tzahal Street, Nes Ziona, and handles real estate transactions, construction defects, condominium disputes and civil litigation. Alongside his legal work he has practical knowledge, not based on formal training, of engineering, appraisal and electrical and building systems, and he personally conducts the cross-examination of experts in construction defects cases.
Questions and answers
Can house committee debt be collected in an ordinary court?
Is the Superintendent's decision like a judgment?
For enforcement and execution, yes. Under section 76 of the Land Law, the Superintendent's decision has the status of a Magistrates' Court judgment.
The tenant did not pay the fees. Who do we collect from?
The duty under the Law is on the apartment owner. An agreement between landlord and tenant about paying the fees does not release the owner towards the building's committee.
The bylaws set a different split. Which prevails?
Under section 58(a), the split by floor area applies only if the bylaws do not set a different share. Registered agreed bylaws that set a different share prevail.
Need a lawyer or a notary?
A short initial consultation call, to understand whether and how we can help.
