052-5927592 17 Tzahal Street, Ness Ziona Sun-Thu 09:00-19:00, Fri 09:00-12:30

Security for Costs in a Claim by a Limited Company

When a limited company sues, the defendant may ask the court to order it to deposit security for the defendant's costs if the defendant wins. This is set out in section 353A of the Companies Law, 1999.

The Supreme Court has held that ordering security is the default and exemption is the exception. The burden of showing why security should not be ordered lies on the company, and it is a heavy burden.

Why must a company deposit security?

Because shareholders of a limited company are not liable for its debts. A defendant who wins may find there is no one to collect the awarded costs from, while the plaintiff shelters behind the company's separate legal personality. Section 353A is designed to prevent this.

Under the section, the court may, at the defendant's request, order the company to provide adequate security for the defendant's costs and stay the proceedings until it is provided, unless it considers that the circumstances do not justify this, or the company proves that it is able to pay the costs.

How does the court decide?

Using a three-stage test summarized in LCA 882/24 Ram Aderet Residences Ltd v. Prosperity N.S. Ltd (2.4.2024): first the company's financial capacity, then whether the circumstances nonetheless justify exemption, and finally the amount of security.

  1. Financial capacity: the court weighs the company's financial position, the amount claimed, the complexity of the case, the need for experts, expected legal fees and the prospects of the claim, to assess whether the company could pay costs if ordered.
  2. Circumstances: if capacity is not proven, the court considers the company's right of access to the courts and the defendant's property right, the parties' good faith and, in extreme cases, the prospects of the claim.
  3. Amount: set according to all the circumstances, including the type and complexity of the claim.

What must the company prove to be exempt?

Substantiated data. The Supreme Court has held that a terse accountant's letter, or general claims of paying debts on time, are not sufficient proof of financial soundness (LCA 9618/11 Art Judaica Ltd v. G. Tali Ad Shinua Ltd). The burden on the company is high (LCA 237/19 Kochav HaYovel Ltd v. El-Har Engineering and Construction Ltd).

  • Financial statements, not just an accountant's letter.
  • Details of cash flow, expenses and liabilities.
  • An explanation of any charges registered against the company and their significance.
  • Assets that can actually be collected from, not merely a claimed property value.

An example from our practice

We represented the defendant in a claim filed against him by Mezuza Holdings Ltd in the Tel Aviv District Court (CC 59346-10-24 Mezuza Holdings Ltd v. Polak), for declaratory relief cancelling the registration of real estate rights registered in his name. With the statement of defence we applied for security. The company claimed it owned a property worth 16 to 18 million ₪ and attached an accountant's letter on rental income.

The court registrar, Yehezkel Eliyahu, granted the application (decision of 24.6.2025). It held that the property value was claimed without supporting evidence; that the company did not address an unlimited-amount charge in favor of a bank shown in its company extract; that the accountant's letter, without financial statements, did not meet the required threshold; and that the annual surplus it showed, after loan repayments, did not justify exemption. The claim of high prospects was also rejected, as prospects should not be assessed at this stage on disputed facts. The company was ordered to deposit security of 80,000 ₪, failing which the claim would be struck out.

When should the application be filed?

As early as possible, usually with the statement of defence. A defendant who waits until a late stage may face a claim of delay. The application should attach an up-to-date company extract and set out the grounds: charges, foreign shareholders, lack of assets or activity, and the expected costs of the proceedings.

Security in a company claim is different from the security every appellant deposits under regulation 135. See appeal and leave to appeal.

Case law and sources

  • Companies Law, 1999, section 353A.
  • LCA 882/24 Ram Aderet Residences Ltd v. Prosperity N.S. Ltd (2.4.2024).
  • LCA 4128/17 Lauderbaie Yachts Ltd v. Taub (29.6.2017).
  • LCA 10905/07 Neot Oasis Hotels Ltd v. Zisser (13.7.2008).
  • LCA 9618/11 Art Judaica Ltd v. G. Tali Ad Shinua Ltd (29.12.2011).
  • LCA 237/19 Kochav HaYovel Ltd v. El-Har Engineering and Construction Ltd (16.1.2019).
  • CC 59346-10-24 Mezuza Holdings Ltd v. Polak (Tel Aviv-Jaffa District Court, registrar's decision of 24.6.2025).

About the author

Amos Ilan, Advocate, is a lawyer (Bar No. 35320) and a notary (licence 214444). The office is at 17 Tzahal Street, Nes Ziona, and handles real estate transactions, construction defects, condominium disputes and civil litigation. Alongside his legal work he has practical knowledge, not based on formal training, of engineering, appraisal and electrical and building systems, and he personally conducts the cross-examination of experts in construction defects cases.

Disclaimer. Nothing in this article constitutes legal advice or a substitute for it. Each case is examined on its own facts and documents.

Questions and answers

Must every company that sues deposit security?

Not automatically. The defendant must apply. But once an application is filed, the default is to order security, and the company must prove it can pay costs or that the circumstances justify exemption.

What happens if the company does not deposit security?

The court may stay the proceedings until security is provided, and usually orders that if it is not deposited on time, the claim will be struck out.

Is an accountant's letter enough for an exemption?

Usually not. The Supreme Court has held that a terse accountant's letter and general claims are not sufficient. Substantiated data, such as financial statements and details of liabilities, is required.

How much security does the court set?

There is no fixed amount. The court estimates expected costs according to the type of claim, its complexity and the need for experts. In the case described, a claim for declaratory relief over real estate, 80,000 ₪ was set.

Need a lawyer or a notary?

A short initial consultation call, to understand whether and how we can help.

Call WhatsApp Form